Family Law — Beyond the Relocation Decision: Preserving Parent–Child Relationships in Family Court Disputes
Family Law
On 23 October 2026, the Family Court granted a mother’s application for permanent relocation of her 13-year-old child to the United Kingdom. In the judgment, the learned Judge rejected the father’s contention that the application was a way of excluding him from the child’s life.
The parents divorced in 2019 and have joint custody of the child of the family. The mother first applied to relocate in 2021 but withdrew that application after an adverse recommendation in the social investigation report. She applied again in January 2024 and the father opposed it. The trial took place in January 2026 and resumed in September 2026.
Applying the Payne guidance, the Court was satisfied that relocation was in the child’s best interests. The Court considered the following factors:
• The child’s wishes. The Court found the child had strong determination to relocate and that his wish to move was “well thought and reasonable” and not pressured by either parent. The child repeatedly expressed his wish to relocate to his parents, the school, social investigation officers and clinical psychologist. He had visited three times with positive experiences and some of his friends have moved there.
• His emotional attachment to his mother. The Court accepted that the mother is the child’s emotional anchor and primary carer. As the mother had to relocate imminently due to the expiry of her visa, refusing the mother’s application meant that the child would be left to the care of his father and his new family in Hong Kong. The Court found that this may lead to the child feeling emotionally isolated and may also adversely affect the mother’s emotionally and psychologically.
• The mother’s relocation plan. The Court found that the mother’s relocation plan was genuine, practical and realistic. The plan duly took into account the child’s ongoing medical follow-up and his difficulties with the Chinese subject. The Court found the schooling plan to be well researched and practical. It also rejected the father’s argument that her plans kept changing. The Court was also satisfied that the mother had sufficient finances and financial means in the event of relocation.
• The Judge’s observations on the father–child relationship. The Court found that the father-child relationship had deteriorated since September 2024 but was now improving. The updated social investigation report showed that the child held back from his father because he feared that a closer relationship might lead the Court to order him to stay in Hong Kong. The learned Judge said that this mistaken belief had to be corrected and that the child must understand that the relocation application is considered independently and that an improved relationship will not adversely affect the application. Whilst the Court found that the mother could have taken more initiative to facilitate the improvement of the father and child relationship, it was not satisfied that the mother had deliberately isolated the father from the child. Instead, the Court found that the mother began to realize her responsibility and did take steps to help improve the father-child relationship, which were effective. By the time of the trial, the child’s relationship with the father had been improving. The Judge urged the father to be more appreciative of the mother’s efforts to improve the relationship. He said that, for it to improve further, the child needs the father’s positive appreciation and encouragement. He also urged both parents to keep repairing the relationship whether or not the application is granted.
Three social investigation reports, an international social investigation report and a clinical psychologist’s report were produced before the Court. The Judge said he had considered them in full but was not bound to follow their recommendations.
• The first social investigation report (2024) did not support relocation. The Judge found it had been overtaken by subsequent events.
• The second and third reports made no recommendation on relocation. Both stressed first restoring the father–child relationship.
• The clinical psychologist described the mother as the child’s emotional anchor. She considered that a well-planned relocation, once confirmed, would spare the child from taking sides and give him space to re-examine his feelings towards his father.
• The updated social investigation report (2026) found the father–child relationship improving and said a binding court order was crucial. The Judge’s own findings on the evidence matched this.
Ultimately, the learned Judge accepted the clinical psychologist’s view that once the relocation is confirmed, it would spare the child from taking sides and give him space to re-examine his feelings towards his father.
An important reminder from this case is that a child’s right to a meaningful relationship with both parents must be protected. Both parents should work towards this goal. Further, a relocation application is considered independently by the Court and a child need not be apprehensive that by appearing too close with the parent remaining in Hong Kong, he may be ordered to stay in Hong Kong against his wishes.
Vivien Leung, instructed by Ivan Lee & Co., acted for the 2nd Applicant (the Mother).
Vivien Leung

“Vivien has already earned a reputation for her razor-sharp advocacy, meticulous preparation and an uncanny ability to connect with witnesses. She combines intellect and passion inspiring confidence.”
“She’s a great listener and definitely very hard-working. She delivers well and handles clients well. She’s also quite flexible when it comes to fees.”
Chambers & Partners Greater China Region 2026, Family/Matrimonial: The Bar— Band 1
Vivien was acknowledged by Chambers and Partners (2026) as a “Band 1” practitioner in Family/Matrimonial Law, and was also recognised by the Legal 500 (Asia-Pacific 2025) as a “Rising Star” in Family and Private Client practice areas.
Vivien advises on all aspects of matrimonial finance and children’s matters and has particular experience in handling divorce cases with a cross-border or international element.
Find out more from Vivien’s profile.
This article was first published on 16 November 2026.
Disclaimer: This article does not constitute legal advice and seeks to set out the general principles of the law. Detailed advice should therefore be sought from a legal professional relating to the individual merits and facts of a particular case. The photographs which appear in this article are included for decorative purposes only and should not be taken as a depiction of any matter to which the case is related. The views and opinions expressed in this article/material are solely those of the members authoring it and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Denis Chang’s Chambers, or of any other member or members of Denis Chang’s Chambers.