Chow J gave Judgment on 2 September 2019 to allow the Election Petition because the returning officer failed to give Agnes Chow a reasonable opportunity to respond to the materials intended to be relied upon by the Returning Officer for the decision that the nomination is invalid.  Chow J further held that such an irregularity […]

This second-ever trial before the Hong Kong Competition Tribunal (“Tribunal”) concerned decoration works undertaken for the tenants of Phase 1 of On Tat Estate, Kwun Tong.  The Competition Commission (“Commission”)’s allegation was that in June – November 2016, the 10 Respondents made or gave effect to an agreement or engaged in a concerted practice among […]

Application for judicial review against the Co-location Arrangement and the creation of the Mainland Port Area at the West Kowloon Station under the Guangzhou-Shenzhen-Hong Kong Express Rail Link (Co-location) Ordinance (Cap. 632). The Court of First Instance granted leave to the applicants to apply for judicial review but dismissed the substantive application. Hectar Pun SC of […]

Appeal to the Court of Final Appeal against conviction under sections 59(1A) and 60(1) of the Crimes Ordinance (Cap. 200). The Court held that taking part in a Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attack, even if it failed to have any effect upon the operation of a computer, nevertheless constituted a misuse of computer under […]

Application for judicial review concerning whether “ding” rights under the Small House Policy are within the “lawful traditional rights and interests of New Territories indigenous inhabitants” in Article 40 of the Basic Law. Application allowed insofar as it relates to Private Treaty Grant and Exchange, being two of the three forms of land grant under […]

The Court of First Instance gave judgments in Silver universe Investment Ltd v China Times Securities Ltd & Others (HCA 1824/2018) on 18 January 2019 and 29 March 2019 granting interlocutory injunctions and enforcing disclosure orders in aid of the injunctions. In the judgment dated 29 March 2019, Deputy High Court Judge Keith Yeung SC […]

The District Court gave judgment in Tam Heung Man v the Incorporated Owners of Lung Poon Court (Block A-F) (DCCJ 4380/2014) on 26 March 2019. This case concerns a libel claim brought by the Plaintiff, who is a District Councillor, against the Defendant in respect of two notices published by the Defendant to the residents of […]

Defence over an injunction sought against the respondents in the case to remove certain structures on roof which were said to be in breach of the DMC of a multistorey building in the Lands Tribunal.

The Court of Appeal gave judgment in Acropolis Limited & another v W&Q Investment Ltd & others (CACV 276 & 277/2017) on 26 March 2018, allowing the appeals of the 1st-4th Defendants and 5th-9th Defendants, overturning the decision of the Court of First Instance (HCA 1496/2017, 31 August 2017) to grant an interim injunction restraining […]